Easy Cultured Yogurt in the Oven

007You won’t believe how easy this is! The trick here- you must have access to raw milk.  It’s too bad we don’t have more access to farm fresh milk to make cultured cheese, butter and yogurt. There are many health benefits found  in fresh milk that has not been pasteurized or homogenized, thereby retaining its healthy living cultures. To read more bout this visit realmilk.com. This recipe is something fun, easy and healthy you can do for your family. I use this yogurt in so many things- pancakes, muffins, salad dressing, dips, smoothies, marinades and on and on! It is a staple for our family, and gives a satisfying feeling  to visit the dairy to pick up my fresh supply of jersey milk, create recipes with it while knowing I am  doing something to support the health of my family! After  you make this save a cup to use to culture your next 1/2 gallon of raw milk, rather than use store bought yogurt the next time!

Step 1:

Turn on oven light and gather supplies.

Supplies needed:

  • 1/2 gallon raw fresh milk
  • Whisk
  • Large clean pot
  • 2 clean large mason jars with lids
  • Funnel ( to make pouring in jars easier)
  • 1/4 c plus 4 Tbs  high quality plain yogurt ( I like using greek yogurt)
  • Oven with oven light and Towel for insulation.


Step 2:

Pour your milk into large pot and heat on medium. (This is hardest part so don’t get sidetracked). Wait until milk is right temperature by using the finger test. (about 8 minutes) That’s right- no fancy thermometers needed!! You will know its right when you test temperature with (clean) finger and feels just to the point of uncomfortably hot! Remove from heat immediately, add 1/4 c of your yogurt and whisk until incorporated.


Step 3:

Add 2 tablespoons of your yogurt to bottom of each empty mason jar. Pour still warm milk until halfway full. Whisk the yogurt and milk together. Add more milk to top of jar. Give another good whisk and repeat with next jar. You will probably have a little left over.


Step 4:

Place lids on jars, put side by side close to oven light. wrap with towel to keep insulated. Close door and leave note with message “do not turn off light or use oven!” Promise  you’ll be glad you did, learned this the hard way! Leave in oven for 24 hours. Yogurt will not be consistency of Greek yogurt but thinner. If thicker yogurt is desired place in tea towel and drain off whey over sink for 6-12 hours.Use whey for added nutrition in smoothies or stocks.  I have found thinner is the desired consistency to use in recipes.Store in fridge and use within 2 weeks. If there is any question with contamination- funny smell, taste or visible growth discard. Don’t forget to save around a cup of your yogurt to make the next batch!


20 thoughts on “Easy Cultured Yogurt in the Oven

  1. Pingback: Cultured Chocolate Chip Cookies | Art to Feed

  2. Pingback: Maple Yogurt Almond Muffins | Art to Feed

  3. Pingback: Citrus Yogurt Chicken with Thyme | Art to Feed

  4. Pingback: Quick Pretzel Crusted Pork Chops | the Art to Feed

  5. Pingback: Soaked Oatmeal | the Art to Feed

  6. Pingback: Creamy Sweet Potato Garden Pasta Sauce | the Art to Feed

  7. Pingback: Wild Black Berry Cobbler | the Art to Feed

  8. Pingback: Peach and Apple Muffins with Vanilla Crumble | the Art to Feed

  9. Pingback: Raw Butter With Yogurt | the Art to Feed

  10. Pingback: Super Moist Pumpkin Muffins…made with yogurt and almond Butter | the Art to Feed

  11. Pingback: Fresh Breakfast Lasagna | the Art to Feed

  12. Pingback: Yogurt Bread Calzones | the Art to Feed

  13. Pingback: Lavender Rosemary Freezer Cookies | the Art to Feed

  14. Pingback: Harvest Short Ribs; Braised in Brown Butter and Tarragon on Bed of Creamy Yogurt Polenta | the Art to Feed

  15. Pingback: Spiced Pear and Pumpkin Yogurt Muffins with Graham Crumble | the Art to Feed

  16. Pingback: Festive Persimmon and Pomegranate Cookies | the Art to Feed

  17. Pingback: Meyer Lemon Cheesecake Cookies; Sprinkled with Cinnamon Sugar and Zest | the Art to Feed

  18. Pingback: Lemon Oat Breakfast Muffins; Learn my Quick, One Pot “Blank Canvas” Recipe! | the Art to Feed

  19. Pingback: Creamy Summer Squash Soup with Roasted Chicken | the Art to Feed

  20. Pingback: Jalapeno Overload; A Confession- Recipe for Cheesy Jalapeno Cauliflower Rice & Beans, and an Aioli | the Art to Feed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s